Dr Govinda KC hunger strike National Medical Education Bill Nepal New parliamentary Health and Education Committee

‘Draft National Medical Education Bill has many flaws’

‘Draft National Medical Education Bill has many flaws’

The Parliamentary Well being and Education Committee handed the draft National Medical Education Bill on the idea of majority and tabled it within the Parliament on Sunday. Lawmakers representing the primary opposition Nepali Congress have written a word of dissent. In the meantime, medical schooling activist Dr Govinda KC began his 16th starvation strike from Ilam. Jagdishor Panday of The Himalayan Occasions caught up with Nepal Communist Celebration (NCP) lawmaker Yogesh Bhattarai and NC lawmaker Gagan Kumar Thapa to speak about points associated to the invoice. Excerpts:

Interview with Nepali Congress lawmaker Gagan Kumar Thapa, in Kathmandu, on Thursday, January 10, 2019. Photograph: Naresh Krishna Shrestha/THT

What prompted you and lawmakers out of your get together to put in writing a observe of dissent on the invoice?

The medical schooling sector is in a multitude. From our expertise and research, we now have concluded that we’d like a high-level fee that oversees the complete medical schooling sector. Though the invoice has provision for such a fee, it has additionally left many loopholes. If we don’t shut these loopholes, the primary objective of bringing this invoice will probably be watered down.

Dr Govinda KC has been preventing for a similar function. When the invoice was tabled within the Parliament Dr KC had been on his 15th starvation strike. The federal government signed an settlement with Dr KC assuring him that the federal government would come with all 9 factors of the settlement reached with him.

We had assumed that no matter the person opinions, the federal government would abide by its commitments. However the authorities retracted on the final second, leaving many points within the sector unaddressed. This prompted us to write down a observe of dissent.

Might you please elaborate the factors within the invoice with which you differ?

Education sector is solely totally different from different sectors. Who’s investing, who’s learning and what high quality is maintained have an effect on the schooling sector. That is in all probability the one sector the place academics and college students usually are not sufficient, the group can also be concerned. That’s why, this sector wants public funding and the federal government ought to take duty. To take such a duty, the federal government has to type a robust supervising organisation first. After forming such a physique, we will usher in non-governmental organisations.

Up to now there’s no such provision. So the invoice is being launched to incorporate that provision. Nevertheless, the invoice has not made public funding obligatory. It favours profit-oriented medical schools.

Additionally, lawmakers of the ruling NCP say the settlement reached with Dr KC doesn’t bar opening medical schools outdoors Kathmandu valley. They are saying the Mathema report has additionally advisable opening medical schools outdoors the valley. What is obvious is that Dr KC is for opening medical schools outdoors the valley, however solely with authorities funding. After the federal government runs medical schools outdoors the valley, personal sector organisations will come to these locations following the federal government’s footsteps.

Furthermore, the invoice states that Tribhuvan College and Kathmandu College ought to situation permission to open medical schools outdoors Kathmandu valley. However can these universities monitor and guarantee high quality in such numerous medical establishments?

NCP lawmakers are additionally spreading hearsay that it isn’t potential to run medical schools outdoors the valley, which is completely flawed. Purvanchal College was about to start out issuing affiliations after Nepal Medical Council allotted it fifty seats, however it couldn’t because it lacked school. If the federal government had strengthened these universities — Purvanchal College, Sudur Paschim College and Mid-western College — they might have run medical schools. However they didn’t achieve this.

The hilarious factor is the invoice proposes revolutionary provisions resembling present for-profit medical schools ought to undertake not-for-profit or belief mannequin progressively within the subsequent 10 years. Nevertheless, it additionally proposes that those that have invested cash and purchased letters of intent must be allowed to make revenue. You must take one aspect, not each.

You’ve additionally expressed reservations over the content material of the invoice’s preamble. Might you elaborate?

The settlement reached with Dr KC states the preamble ought to embrace the identify of Mathema Fee. That is logical as a result of the invoice has been ready on the idea of the Mathema Fee’s report. However out of the blue, the invoice has proposed a medical college based mostly on a report of a judicial fee headed by Gauri Bahadur Karki. So not together with Mahema Fee’s identify within the preamble is guided by the intention of together with provisions beneficial by numerous commissions, committees and task-forces shaped in several occasions only for the aim of justification.

Additionally, the invoice shouldn’t be clear what sort of medical college it’s. The invoice has barred opening medical schools contained in the valley for the subsequent 10 years, however it doesn’t bar opening a medical college. Even Education Minister (Giriraj Mani Pokharel) was towards such a provision. This is a chance for Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli, who signed the settlement with Dr KC, to implement it, and show his critics fallacious. He has the chance to go the fee and reform the sector. This may also present him a fantastic plank for the subsequent common elections after 4 years. Nevertheless it appears he’s lacking that chance.

As for difficulties in managing these schools which have already acquired letters of intent, regional universities may be strengthened and people establishments may be issued affiliations.

What are the invoice’s constructive elements?

A number of the constructive points of the invoice embrace provision of a high-level fee to supervise the medical schooling sector, together with health-related programmes of CTEVT and moratorium on opening new medical schools within the valley for the subsequent 10 years. The invoice has barred a college from issuing affiliations to greater than 5 medical schools. Nevertheless, the federal government isn’t dedicated to implementing these constructive provisions as is clear from the truth that the federal government has provisioned a medical college mysteriously.

What’s your tackle Dr KC’s 16th starvation strike?

Let me not touch upon the best way he speaks or the language he makes use of. The motion would have gained extra traction had he spoken correctly. Nevertheless, Dr KC is a unique individual. He isn’t preventing for particular person profit.

The federal government signed an settlement with Dr KC and it’s in no temper to implement it. PM Oli has a chance because the parliamentary get together chief of the ruling get together. He can deliver again the invoice heading in the right direction inside a minute. The ball is now within the PM’s courtroom. Individuals say the NC is resorting to propaganda because it doesn’t have any agenda. If so, we will probably be left agenda-less if the PM solves this drawback.

‘Don’t know why Dr KC is dissatisfied, invoice fufils most calls for’

Interview with Nepal Communist Social gathering (NCP) lawmaker Yogesh Bhattarai, in Kathmandu, on Thursday, January 10, 2019. Photograph: Naresh Krishna Shrestha/THT

What’s there within the National Medical Education Bill that prompted Nepali Congress lawmakers to write down word of dissent and Dr KC to start out his 16th starvation strike?

The committee handed the invoice after round 26 rounds of conferences within the sub-committee. We additionally held consultations with specialists, stakeholders, and people who help and oppose Dr KC’s calls for. Sadly, we couldn’t maintain session with Dr KC as he refused to speak. It was a misplaced alternative for each Dr KC and the Home committee.

The rationale behind introducing this invoice is to resolve points associated to the medical schooling sector. The invoice consists of, in crystal-clear phrases, some essential factors that Dr KC has raised. The invoice has barred opening of medical schools in Kathmandu Valley for the subsequent 10 years. The cope with Dr KC states that medical schools ought to be opened outdoors the valley. So the invoice provisions a minimum of one medical school in every of the seven provinces and people schools ought to be run by the federal government. This implies the federal government has to compulsorily open medical schools in Province 2 and Sudurpaschim Province the place there isn’t a medical school.

The invoice additionally provisions medical college. There’s a development whereby a college points affiliation to medical schools even when it doesn’t have its personal medical division. As for the notion that the federal government ought to run the well being and schooling sectors — assured by the structure’s elementary rights — it won’t be sensible for the federal government to try this instantly. However the authorities can do it regularly. For that we’ve got requested medical schools presently beneath operation to progressively undertake the not-for-profit mannequin and convert into service-based establishments. We have now given them 10 years for it.

We’re of the view that establishments which have acquired letters of intent and have constructed crucial infrastructure ought to be allowed to function, however they are going to be suspended in the event that they fail to satisfy the set standards and requirements.

To keep away from query paper leaks, the invoice envisions built-in entrance examination system. Nepali college students learning in Nepali schools, foreigners coming to review in Nepal, and Nepalis wanting to review drugs in overseas nations ought to cross the Central Entrance System carried out by Nepal Medical Council. This provision will management high quality. Now onwards, a medical school ought to have hospitals with at the very least 300 beds working for at the least three years. A high-level fee led by the prime minister has been proposed to supervise the well being schooling sector.

Why did NC lawmakers write word of dissent and Dr KC begin starvation strike?

They’ve expressed dissatisfaction primarily over three factors. The primary is said to phasing out short-term medical programs run by CTEVT. Dr KC has demanded phasing out of such programs inside the subsequent 5 years. Theoretically, there’s no drawback. However virtually, it might be troublesome. So the invoice has provisioned both phasing out, upgrading or scrapping after essential research. We simply added the phrase ‘upgrading’, and the remaining is according to Dr KC’s demand. We’ve got not been in a position to determine what’s flawed in upgrading a course whether it is mandatory.

The second level is said to the invoice’s preamble. The settlement reached with Dr KC states that the preamble ought to embrace the phrase that ‘the bill has been drafted in the spirit of the Mathema Commission report’. However doing so is just not in follow internationally. Additionally, no regulation within the nation has to date included such a phrase.  The language was generalised.

There are a number of commissions, committees and activity forces that studied the matter and got here up with reviews, resembling that headed by Gauri Bahadur Karki. How might we solely write one fee’s identify? Though it’s generalised, we now have included the Mathema Fee within the preamble as per the settlement with Dr KC, however I have no idea why NC lawmakers wrote the notice of dissent.

The third level is the invoice’s provision that universities can problem affiliation to solely 5 medical schools, however those that have already constructed infrastructure and brought letters of intent ought to be allowed to function outdoors Kathmandu valley. That is only a one-time measure for many who have already invested an enormous sum of money. It won’t be good to inflict big financial loss on them.

I need to ask my pals from the NC what’s mistaken in selling funding. An enormous sum of money goes outdoors the nation yearly in charges of scholars pursuing medical schooling overseas. Is it flawed to curb the financial outflow?

Additionally, most of these learning overseas fail within the Medical Council examination, however greater than 80 per cent of these learning in Nepal cross. I have no idea if Dr KC doesn’t perceive this, or he’s being provoked by others. So far as the NC is worried, it additionally objected to the supply of medical college. There are specialised universities in different disciplines, corresponding to agriculture and Sanskrit. So what’s incorrect with medical college? I feel they lack understanding.

The cope with Dr KC was registered within the Parliament. Why was it excluded from the invoice?

As you recognize the Parliament is a unique entity. It has its personal features and guidelines. The settlement additionally states that will probably be carried out on the idea of parliamentary norms and values, and we’ve adopted these norms and values. It isn’t that the Parliament ought to do no matter the federal government wishes. For those who take a look at the case of Supreme Courtroom Justice Deepak Raj Joshi, the parliamentary committee rejected his nomination for the submit of chief justice although the Constitutional Council really helpful him.

What’s your view on Dr KC’s starvation strike?

I feel it’s time he celebrated as a result of the invoice has provisioned no matter he demanded. He must be pleased with himself. I don’t know why he’s staging one other starvation strike once more. He’s utilizing foul language towards some outstanding leaders. It’s going to hurt none aside from him. However I need to inform the NC they need to cease utilizing Dr KC to serve their vested curiosity.


A model of this text seems in print on January 14, 2019 of The Himalayan Occasions.

Comply with The Himalayan Occasions on

(perform(d, s, id)
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0];
if (d.getElementById(id)) return;
js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id;
js.src = “//connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js#xfbml=1&version=v2.4&appId=211856115514232”;
fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs);
(doc, ‘script’, ‘facebook-jssdk’));